• About
  • Adam Hengels
  • Emily Hamilton
  • Michael Lewyn
  • Salim Furth
  • What Should I Read to Understand Zoning?
  • Contact

Market Urbanism

Liberalizing cities | From the bottom up

“Market Urbanism” refers to the synthesis of classical liberal economics and ethics (market), with an appreciation of the urban way of life and its benefits to society (urbanism). We advocate for the emergence of bottom up solutions to urban issues, as opposed to ones imposed from the top down.

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Economics
  • housing
  • planning
  • Zoning
  • Urban[ism] Legends
  • Book Reviews

The Moral Case Against Rent Control

October 16, 2008 By Adam Hengels

In Market Urbanism’s four part series on rent control, I avoided the topic of the morality of rent control, as I intended to address the economic issues and leave the morality to others. Thankfully, J. Brian Phillips of the Ad Hoc Committee for Property Rights is an expert on the subject. In his blog, he linked to the recent Retail Rent Control post, and took the time to address the moral issue:

But the real issue isn’t political. The real issue is moral. A large part of the public sees nothing wrong with forcing others to provide for their wants and desires. And there is a steady stream of politicians all too eager to propose laws to grant them their wishes. They think that their wishes can somehow transform reality, that if they pass a law with the intention of creating affordable widgets, affordable widgets will result. They think that politicians are nothing more than genies who can grant their wish simply by writing a law. It doesn’t work that way. Reality is not malleable to one’s wishes.

He makes plenty of good points, so I recommend reading the whole post. He concludes:

Each individual has a moral right to live for his own happiness. He has a right to the fruits of his labor. He has a right to pursue his values without intervention from others, so long as he respects their mutual rights. Human beings are not sacrificial animals.

Also, here’s another another article on the morality of rent control: Why Rent Control is Immoral by Michael S. Berliner, Ph.D.

The morality issue belongs as a prominent part of the rent control discussion, but is seldom heard among all the progressive anti-market rhetoric.

Tweet

Filed Under: rent control Tagged With: J. Brian Phillips, property rights, rent control

About Adam Hengels

Adam is passionate about urbanism, and founded this site in 2007, after realizing that classical liberals and urbanists actually share many objectives, despite being at odds in many spheres of the intellectual discussion. His mission is to improve the urban experience, and overcome obstacles that prevent aspiring city dwellers from living where they want. http://www.marketurbanism.com/adam-hengels/

Comments

  1. DVA says

    October 16, 2008 at 3:53 pm

    I actually find the moral argument much less compelling than the usual economic arguments (i.e. price controls create shortages, and oh look, there’s a chronic shortage of housing here in NYC). To play devil’s advocate here, the easy response to this is that privileges come with responsibilities, and that the privilege of having the government enforce your property rights comes with the responsibility of using those rights in certain ways. In a similar vein, you have a moral right to do as you like with what you own, but only insofar as it doesn’t harm others. This latter argument hinges on one valuing community: the harm referred to is not the end of one particular transaction when someone loses their lease to unaffordable rent increases, it’s the steady erosion of that community as this happens repeatedly. (The destruction of the community, being non-quantifiable, is then an externality that the market doesn’t deal with.)

  2. DVA says

    October 16, 2008 at 3:53 pm

    I actually find the moral argument much less compelling than the usual economic arguments (i.e. price controls create shortages, and oh look, there’s a chronic shortage of housing here in NYC). To play devil’s advocate here, the easy response to this is that privileges come with responsibilities, and that the privilege of having the government enforce your property rights comes with the responsibility of using those rights in certain ways. In a similar vein, you have a moral right to do as you like with what you own, but only insofar as it doesn’t harm others. This latter argument hinges on one valuing community: the harm referred to is not the end of one particular transaction when someone loses their lease to unaffordable rent increases, it’s the steady erosion of that community as this happens repeatedly. (The destruction of the community, being non-quantifiable, is then an externality that the market doesn’t deal with.)

  3. DVA says

    October 16, 2008 at 3:53 pm

    I actually find the moral argument much less compelling than the usual economic arguments (i.e. price controls create shortages, and oh look, there’s a chronic shortage of housing here in NYC). To play devil’s advocate here, the easy response to this is that privileges come with responsibilities, and that the privilege of having the government enforce your property rights comes with the responsibility of using those rights in certain ways. In a similar vein, you have a moral right to do as you like with what you own, but only insofar as it doesn’t harm others. This latter argument hinges on one valuing community: the harm referred to is not the end of one particular transaction when someone loses their lease to unaffordable rent increases, it’s the steady erosion of that community as this happens repeatedly. (The destruction of the community, being non-quantifiable, is then an externality that the market doesn’t deal with.)

Trackbacks

  1. laser inspection says:
    February 24, 2014 at 6:21 pm

    … [Trackback]

    […] Read More here: marketurbanism.com/2008/10/16/the-moral-case-against-rent-control/ […]

Listen in

  • Abundance
  • Conversations with Tyler
  • Densely Speaking
  • Ideas of India
  • Order Without Design
  • UCLA Housing Voice
  • Yeoman

Connect With Us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Market Sites Urbanists should check out

  • Arpitrage
  • Cafe Hayek
  • Center for Building in North America blog
  • Construction Physics
  • Conversable Economist
  • Environmental and Urban Economics | Matt Kahn
  • Erdmann Housing Tracker
  • Foundation for Economic Education
  • Marginal Revolution
  • Marginal Revolution University
  • Parafin
  • Propmodo
  • Rent Free
  • Time & Space
  • Urbanomics

Urbanism Sites capitalists should check out

  • Caos Planejado
  • City Density
  • Cornerstone
  • Granola Shotgun
  • Important Readings in Urbanism
  • Kartografia Ekstremalna
  • Metropolitan Abundance Project
  • Pedestrian Observations
  • Planetizen
  • Reinventing Parking
  • Skynomics Blog
  • StreetsBlog USA
  • Strong Towns
  • The Corner Side Yard | Pete Saunders
  • YIMBY Alliance

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Copyright © 2025 Market Urbanism